![]() |
Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - Printable Version +- MacResource (https://forums.macresource.com) +-- Forum: My Category (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: 'Friendly' Political Ranting (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=6) +--- Thread: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel (/showthread.php?tid=296018) |
Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - pdq - 04-26-2025 DeusxMac wrote: Would that be Aukland, the most populous city in wild-and-drug-crazy New Zealand? I mean, sure - that’s should be enough to arrest kids with valid travel docs, cuff them, strip search them (finding no drugs), put them in prison garb, throw them in a cell overnight, and then deport them. That’s just standard practice for tourists, right? As the linked article notes: While most international visitors experience no issues entering Hawaii, this case serves as a cautionary reminder that what works in other countries may not work when dealing with U.S. immigration authorities. They should gave added: …these days. Stories like this could impact Hawaii’s image, particularly among international visitors facing high costs and growing overtourism concerns. Gee, ya think? Oh, but I forgot. The Secretary of State has reassured foreign visitors that they have nothing to worry about: United States Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, has tried to ease concerns of European travelers wanting to visit the USA by saying, “If you’re not coming to the United States to join a Hamas protest, or to come here and tell us about how right Hamas is, or…stir up conflict on our campuses and create riots in our streets and vandalize our universities, then you have nothing to worry about.” But I guess that reassurance is no longer operative, huh? Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - JoeH - 04-26-2025 Little Marco's lips were moving, we all know what that means. Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - Acer - 04-26-2025 You should not be punished when you have met every legal requirement. If tourists must have all accommodations booked on entry, then make it a law. "We'll tell you what the rule was after you break it." Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - DeusxMac - 04-26-2025 I'm gonna call some overzealous. knee-jerk responses here. They weren't "deported", they were denied entry; not the same thing. From the full Newsweek article: "...visiting countries like Thailand and New Zealand..." "...they were denied entry after attempting to enter the U.S. under false pretenses. One used a Visitor visa, the other the Visa Waiver Program. Both claimed they were touring California but later admitted they intended to work—something strictly prohibited under U.S. immigration laws for these visas." "Germany's Foreign Ministry says on its website: 'Neither a valid ESTA authorization nor a valid U.S. visa constitutes a right to entry into the USA. The final decision regarding entry is made by the US.. border official. It is recommended that you bring proof of your return journey (e.g., flight booking) upon entry'" Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - pdq - 04-27-2025 DeusxMac wrote: Thailand is the top vacation/tourist destination in Asia for Germans and Europeans in general. (It’s tropical, beach-y, cheap and relatively safe.) You think they’re all drug mules? "...they were denied entry after attempting to enter the U.S. under false pretenses. One used a Visitor visa, the other the Visa Waiver Program. Both claimed they were touring California but later admitted they intended to work—something strictly prohibited under U.S. immigration laws for these visas." Have you missed the accounts of all of these ICE detentions? They always want you to sign something. Do you really believe two teenagers paid for trans-Pacific flights, spending time in Thailand and New Zealand, all in order to earn minimum wage in the US (which is considerably lower than in Germany)? Don’t be so gullible. "Germany's Foreign Ministry says on its website: 'Neither a valid ESTA authorization nor a valid U.S. visa constitutes a right to entry into the USA…. I would guess every country reserves such a right, kinda like businesses/bars that reserve the right to deny service to anyone (if they’re drunk/loud/troublesome). But they don’t toss customers at random because the owner thinks the place is too crowded. And most countries don’t force visitors who have invested money and effort to visit and spend money to turn around and fly back to another country. You’re right it’s not a “deportation”, since they were never here - but it’s the same result (except they fortunately didn’t end up in a supermax prison!). Honestly, some skepticism, please. Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - special - 04-27-2025 it's all smoke and mirrors. They want to show MAGA they do *something*. Germans, Canadians, Mexicans, does not matter as long as they can throw someone in ICE detention for a few days and then put them on a plane. Mission accomplished! Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - pdq - 04-27-2025 special wrote: Agreed. How does this make America great? Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - DeusxMac - 04-27-2025 pdq wrote: Thailand is the top vacation/tourist destination in Asia for Germans and Europeans in general. (It’s tropical, beach-y, cheap and relatively safe.) You think they’re all drug mules? Just said it was a "red flag" for immigration officers, not "all". And what does a "drug mule" look like? If you know, I'm sure customs would love to hear from you. "Southeast Asia is notorious for its drug production, especially methamphetamines and opiates. Thailand, in particular, has a long history of being a significant player in this trade. The Golden Triangle, an area that overlaps Thailand, Laos, and Myanmar, is one of the world's largest opium-producing regions. However, the scope of Thailand's drug trafficking extends beyond opiates; synthetic drugs like methamphetamine have surged in production and popularity in recent years. Data from the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC indicates that the region has seen a dramatic increase in the production of methamphetamines, leading to rampant trafficking operations. This escalation can be attributed to a combination of factors, including poverty, weak law enforcement, and corruption, which enable organized crime syndicates to thrive." https://thailandfocusguide.com/blog/how-drugs-travel-thailand-australia/ pdq wrote:"...they were denied entry after attempting to enter the U.S. under false pretenses. One used a Visitor visa, the other the Visa Waiver Program. Both claimed they were touring California but later admitted they intended to work—something strictly prohibited under U.S. immigration laws for these visas." Again, "refused entry" is not "ICE dentetion", nor "deportation". And, if they admitted they had actually planned to work while holding non-work-authorized visas...(td) pdq wrote:"Germany's Foreign Ministry says on its website: 'Neither a valid ESTA authorization nor a valid U.S. visa constitutes a right to entry into the USA…. Indeed, and perhaps less overdramatization? :peace: Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - pdq - 04-27-2025 DeusxMac wrote: The pair were ultimately taken to a detention facility, with officers telling them they would have to leave the country the following day. They were able to reschedule their Tokyo flight to accommodate the directive, but first had to spend a harrowing night behind bars dressed in green prison uniforms. That kinda sounds like “detention” to me (or worse, actually). And, if they admitted they had actually planned to work while holding non-work-authorized visas...(td) …and 5 kids independently “admitted” to nearly murdering a woman in Central Park, but had nothing to do with it. (Trump said they should have been executed, BTW). But that never happens with CBP/ICE, right? In this case, …the biggest strike against the teens, they said, was that they mentioned during their interview that they occasionally did “small freelance jobs online.” While they claimed not to have any customers in the U.S., this led agents to believe they were attempting to work illegally during their time in the country. :RollingEyesSmiley5: Again, some skepticism, please. I don’t think this is overdramatization. Young female tourists with valid visas were taken into custody, interrogated, strip searched and thrown behind bars overnight before they were forced out of the country. You should have a damn good reason for that. At least it used to be that way. Re: Trump Admin Deports German Tourists For Not Booking A Hotel - dk62 - 04-27-2025 Whether they said anything to immigration about intending to work is really questionable. They would have to be stupid to do that and CBP is apparently lying with increasing frequency. Example: https://newrepublic.com/post/194303/us-citizen-detained-10-days-dhs-lied Deportation and refusal of entry are logistically the same when you arrive by plane. But detention is not warranted. And it is definitely true that the immigration officers have the discretion. I know of an a$$hole who returned a valid visa-holding 60-year old grandma from Canadian border based on personal ethnic animosity. |