+- MacResource (https://forums.macresource.com)
+-- Forum: My Category (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Tips and Deals (https://forums.macresource.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Thread: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! (/showthread.php?tid=55379)
Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - BigGuynRusty - 05-22-2008
Snippet.:
"Overly expensive players, unspectacular features, and a lack of competition will put a quick end to the Blu-ray's victory dance.
By Lance Ulanoff
People amaze me. They truly believe that because the format war is over, we can all sit back and enjoy a steady stream of cheap Blu-ray players, media, and content. What economics class did these people attend?
Sony's victory over HD-DVD left just one format standing─and absolutely no competition. The lack of competition means that prices are likely to remain inordinately high or, even worse, they can go up. Yeah, you heard right. Examples of this kind of thing abound: Look no further than the broadband market to understand how this all works."
Non-Gleaning Linky.:
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,2307354,00.asp
BGnR
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - mattkime - 05-22-2008
ug, there will be competition between different manufacturers and that will push prices down.
duh!
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - BigGuynRusty - 05-22-2008
[quote mattkime]ug, there will be competition between different manufacturers and that will push prices down.
duh! Duh!!
When??
Sony is holding all the keys, the "Window of Opportunity" is closing very quickly.
BGnR
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - Drakesgirl - 05-22-2008
The "battle" involved manufacturers deciding which technology they would go with. The manufacturers have sided now with Sony. Once the initial rush settles, these manufacturers will be doing all they can to lower prices in competition with each other. Sony will ultimately still "hold the keys" to the technology, but the manufacturers will be in control of all the other factors in production costs, and that's where we'll start to see competitive pricing.
Chill, man.
Go buy a PS3.
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - N-OS X-tasy! - 05-22-2008
The real battle will be to displace DVD, just as the format war between DVD and DiVX in the late '90s was to determine which format would go up against VHS.
Stupid article.
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - mikebw - 05-22-2008
I called them out on this too, a couple weeks before it happened I believe (somewhere on this forum). In a way, HD-DVD took the lead even after they dropped out with all their clearance pricing and offers for free discs.
After reading about the HDMI 1.2 and 1.3 specs, it seems that the feature set we currently have for BluRay is pretty much never going to change. I don't know exactly what else people could ask for, but the PS3 seems to have it all, in terms of audio formats anyway. If they were to change the standard now that would effectively alienate all the previously sold BluRay players in the world.
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - BigGuynRusty - 05-22-2008
[quote Drakesgirl]The "battle" involved manufacturers deciding which technology they would go with. The manufacturers have sided now with Sony. Once the initial rush settles, these manufacturers will be doing all they can to lower prices in competition with each other. Sony will ultimately still "hold the keys" to the technology, but the manufacturers will be in control of all the other factors in production costs, and that's where we'll start to see competitive pricing.
Chill, man.
Go buy a PS3.
Sorry, I never get sucked into "marginally better tech for a lot more $$$", just as with music, folks are gonna vote for convenience and speed, not a barely discernible at five feet picture upgrade.Beta, HD, BluRay in the DustBin of history.
BGnR
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - Drakesgirl - 05-22-2008
[quote BigGuynRusty]Sorry, I never get sucked into "marginally better tech for a lot more $$$", just as with music, folks are gonna vote for convenience and speed, not a barely discernible at five feet picture upgrade.
Beta, HD, BluRay in the DustBin of history.
Hang on, are you saying the difference between a regular DVD and a Blu-ray DVD is only barely discernible at five feet?
Are you BLIND?
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - N-OS X-tasy! - 05-22-2008
I just went back and read the entire article -- really stupid article. The guy makes so many incorrect analogies and draws so many incorrect conclusions I'm embarrassed for him.
Re: Sony Wins the Battle But Loses the War. Some of us knew this would happen!! - BigGuynRusty - 05-22-2008
[quote Drakesgirl][quote BigGuynRusty]Sorry, I never get sucked into "marginally better tech for a lot more $$$", just as with music, folks are gonna vote for convenience and speed, not a barely discernible at five feet picture upgrade.
Beta, HD, BluRay in the DustBin of history.
Hang on, are you saying the difference between a regular DVD and a Blu-ray DVD is only barely discernible at five feet?
Are you BLIND? Ask Popular Science, it was their statement.
BGnR