Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Parents are following Kennedy's advice, treating measles with vitamin A... and destroying their kids' livers...
#1
https://skynews.icu/health/816263-for-so...-more-ill/

Doctors in West Texas are seeing measles patients whose illnesses have been complicated by an alternative therapy endorsed by vaccine skeptics including Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the health secretary.

Parents in Gaines County, Texas, the center of a raging measles outbreak, have increasingly turned to supplements and unproven treatments to protect their children, many of whom are unvaccinated, against the virus...

At high doses, vitamin A can cause liver damage; dry, peeling skin; hair loss; and, in rare instances, seizures and coma. So far, doctors at West Texas hospitals have said they’ve seen patients with yellowed skin and high levels of liver enzymes in their bloodwork, both signs of a damaged liver...

Health officials said the recent popularity of vitamin A use for measles could be traced back to a Fox News interview with Mr. Kennedy, in which he said he had heard of “almost miraculous and instantaneous recovery” with treatments like cod liver oil, which he said was “the safest application of vitamin A.”

In an opinion essay for The Washington Post on Tuesday afternoon, Kevin Griffis, who was until last week the communications director at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, wrote that he had resigned in part because of Mr. Kennedy’s handling of the outbreak.

“In my final weeks at the C.D.C., I watched as career infectious-disease experts were tasked with spending precious hours searching medical literature in vain for data to support Kennedy’s preferred treatments,” Mr. Griffis wrote.

In the weeks after the Fox News interview, drugstores in West Texas struggled to keep vitamin A and cod liver oil supplements on their shelves. “I did not hear anything about vitamin A until he said it on television,” said Katherine Wells, the director of public health in Lubbock...

Unlike other vitamins, which are flushed out of the body through urine, excess vitamin A accumulates in fat tissue, making it more likely to reach dangerous levels over time.

“That kind of preventative use I think is especially concerning,” said Dr. Lara Johnson, another doctor at the Lubbock hospital.

“When we have kids taking it for weeks and weeks, then you do potentially have a cumulative impact of the toxicity,” she added.

Dr. Johnson added that local physicians were particularly concerned about parents’ relying on over-the-counter supplements — whose labels don’t always accurately reflect the amount of vitamin they contain — and accepting dosage recommendations from unverified sources.



"Unverified sources" now includes the United States Secretary of Health and Human Services.
Reply
#2
“In my final weeks at the C.D.C., I watched as career infectious-disease experts were tasked with spending precious hours searching medical literature in vain for data to support Kennedy’s preferred treatments,” Mr. Griffis wrote.

When I was a kid, one of my teachers gave us a definition of science vs propaganda which stuck with me.

Science, she said, is the process of making observations to come to a conclusion.

Propaganda starts with a conclusion, and then seeks out observations to support it.
Reply
#3
These people who can't find anything about Vitamin A and measles prior to Krazy Kennedy's interview...do they have Google?

Our own NIH website has many articles on this topic going back decades. Kennedy is wrong to promote any health advice outside of what doctors currently recommend, no question. He needs to stfu. He is doing harm.

But he did not pull the Vitamin A stuff out of his ass.

Here's a 20 year old NIH article.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7076287/


We obviously have a big problem in our country with distrust of science. Articles like the one linked on the OP do not help because they fail to acknowledge that there are associations between Vitamin A doses and reduced measles symptoms in young children. But there are serious risks and in the US we have much better options. Parents need to listen to pediatricians.

That should be the media message. Tell the whole story.
Reply
#4
Okay. Yup, giving vitamin A to third-world children who are deficient in it does appear to help outcomes when/after such kids contract measles.

That is very, very different than pushing Vitamin A on children not deficient in Vitamin A (which probably describes most kids in the developed world, including us), and certainly when used as a preventative for measles, which it most certainly is not.
Reply
#5
pdq wrote:
Okay. Yup, giving vitamin A to third-world children who are deficient in it does appear to help outcomes when/after such kids contract measles.

That is very, very different than pushing Vitamin A on children not deficient in Vitamin A (which probably describes most kids in the developed world, including us), and certainly when used as a preventative for measles, which it most certainly is not.

That is some of the info that needs to be out in media. Not just "these parents are idiot Fox watchers, nobody ever heard of Vitamin A treatments for measles."

Context matters and you don't persuade people by calling them idiots.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)