Posts: 24,926
Threads: 4,391
Joined: Nov 2024
Reputation:
0
My Mom got a big bottle of it because she saw a waterbug and a few millipede-looking bugs. I tried to tell her how dangerous insecticides can be, but it just doesn't register with her. Is there a "smoking gun" website that says for sure it's either bad stuff or safe? I didn't find one with google because all the big words made my eyes glaze over.
Posts: 2,956
Threads: 653
Joined: Feb 2024
The pyrethrin-related insecticides like this are chemically related to what occurs in chrysanthemums. They replaced much more toxic (to humans) insecticides over the years. One of them is the active ingredient in NIX, a head lice treatment, that has been approved for sale by the FDA, not an easy approval to obtain. If she doesn't drink it she ought not come to any harm.
Posts: 8,734
Threads: 487
Joined: Feb 2011
Reputation:
0
It looks to me like the bottom line is that if it's used carefully and according to directions, you're overreacting. Now whether or not it will kill the bugs is a different issue.
Posts: 26,015
Threads: 2,901
Joined: May 2025
Reputation:
1
I tried using that to keep aphids away from my dill.
It didn't work very well. I had to spray every couple of days.
Dill is the only herb I've had trouble growing.
Posts: 26,015
Threads: 2,901
Joined: May 2025
Reputation:
1
That site said dill repels aphids.
They feasted on my dill!
Posts: 4,915
Threads: 267
Joined: Dec 2024
Reputation:
0
It's pretty much the only pesticide I use, and it's mostly to keep ants from using the crawlspace vents to gain access to the crawlspace and house. I also spray it around the bases of a scale-prone eugenia and berry vines to keep ants from farming the scale. It does last 3 or 4 months. Makes my nose run, though. The next step up might be deltamethrin. Most people would trade a little risk of toxicity to have a house free of creepy bugs.
The previous owners of this house left me a shed full of herbicides, miticides, fungicides, and pesticides. I tried to keep up with their regimen because if I didn't, the insects got out of control. When we had a baby, I stopped using them, and it took a year and a half but now the pests are kept in check by beneficials. Whiteflies and mealybugs are nearly gone. I have aphids on the roses, but not as many, because there are plenty of ladybug larvae too. I've got lizards and frogs in the yard now.
As for aphids on dill, I would think maybe the plants are getting too much nitrogen. I'd go hunt down some ladybug larvae and move them onto the plants (adults aren't much help). If that didn't work, I'd try some neem oil or soap. I'd be wary of using any pesticide that provides long-lasting protection on anything I planned to harvest and eat.