DVR search . . .

[Bill in NC]

$20/month for a cable DVR vs. buying a used TivoHD w/ lifetime for $300.

Leasing is always more expensive in the long run.

Robert M wrote:
mspace,

I know you said you didn't want to use the TimeWarner DVR. This intrigues me since I've found the DVRs from Cablevision and Verizon FIOS more than sufficient for the job. One of my issues with TIVO is the cost of admission and then the ongoing costs or the cost of lifetime service. I calculated the costs and it'd take years to recoup the investment if I went for a new TIVO with lifetime. Years. Not just one or two. Four or five if I remember correctly.

Money was one reason. the other reason is longevity of the hardware. lifetime service is tied to the TIVO itself. So, if it breaks out of warranty, you need to fix it yourself (if possible), pay to have it fixed or replace it. All at a cost to you, the owner. The Toshiba TIVO DVD Recorder I had required repairs twice. One under warranty via a double the manufacturer's warranty program, the other out of my pocket. The TIVO HD models I had were garbage. It makes me very hesitant to purchase TIVO hardware.

Admittedly, the models i question are from many years ago but the expense and annoyance factor still comes into play. Hopefully newer TIVO hardware is more reliable. At least with a cable provider DVR, if it breaks, you call them and they give you another one. There is something to be said for that. Funny... I've never had to replace a cable or FIOS DVR.

The Timewarner model my wife had for several years worked perfectly until the day she moved and had to return it. The DVRs from Cablevision I had performed flawlessly. Same goes now for the FIOS DVRs in my apartment (both the old before moving and the new one in my new place) and the DVRs in place at my parent's house.

I used a newer TIVO when visiting my brother The interface and usability may be better than the cable provider DVRs but it isn't so much better that I'd consider switching to one. TIVO would seriously need to up their game before I'd consider giving their hardware another chance.

I guess you could say I'm suggesting that you not dismiss the TimeWarner DVR without first checking it out. The DVRs from cable providers have come a _very_ long way over the years. Just an alternate point of view.

Robert