Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
[FIRST IMPRESSIONS] Sans Digital TowerSTOR TS1CT+ Firewire 800/Esata/USB 3.0 enclosure
#1
[FIRST IMPRESSIONS] Sans Digital TowerSTOR TS1CT+ Firewire 800/Esata/USB 3.0 enclosure

Hi everyone,

I jumped on the deal for one of the Sans Digital TowerSTOR TS1CT+ Firewire 800/Esata/USB 3.0 enclosures. Even at $35.00 (after promo code), this was a bargain. I received it this afternoon and here are my impressions of it.

I opened the box and was pleasantly surprised by how nicely Sans Digital packages this model. The enclosure itself is encased in a plastic bag and nestled between pieces of plasticky foam. It definitely isn't going to bounce around in its box and there is ample room to dissipate the occasional bonk. A piece of cardboard separates it from the wall wart-style AC adapter, hard disk mounting screws, Esata cable, Firewire 800 cable and USB 3.0 cable. Yups. Sans Digital provides all three. Very nice! The instructions are a single piece of folded paper that are super easy to follow.

I removed the enclosure itself from the box and it is definitely not a generic piece of garbage. It is well finished and, unlike many of the cheap enclosures I've used over the years, reasonably solid. Not Wiebetech solid - they're the standard by which I measure enclosures - but nice nonetheless. Definitely a step above the generic stuff you'll see at the local electronics store.

The TowerSTOR TS1CT+ is a two piece, slide-apart design that is held together by four small screws. It has two Firewire 800 ports, an Esata port, a USB 3.0 port, an on/off switch. All are on the back. The top of the enclosure has a little window through which an LED shines. The screws that hold the two parts of the enclosure together are not standard size screws, so its best not to lose them. 'course, if that happens, duct tape will work just as well as them. I removed the screws and slid the parts apart. Actually, duct-tape as a replacement won't be necessary because Sans Digital includes some spares. I found them after I opened the little baggy with the mounting screws in it. The bag also had four silicon feet for the enclosure itself. A very nice touch.

The difference between the innards of this enclosure and the Seagate model I reviewed recently is readiyl apparent. Actually, the difference between it and a Sabrant enclosure I bought several years ago is also apparent. Unlike the Seagate, the chassis of this enclosure is nice and solid. I could easily bend the one in the Seagate. Definitely wouldn't be so easy to do with the TowerSTOR chassis. Unlike the Sabrent, the finishing of the TowerSTOR is nice and there is room to spare for the drive. I had to work to get the drive into the Sabrant. That definitely won't be necessary with the TowerSTOR TS1CT+.

The design of the chassis and enclosure appears to allow for ample airflow. Someone definitely put some though into it. The hard disk drive sits on two rails. To install the drive, you gently slide it to the SATA connector. They line up perfectly. To make the connection, give the drive a gentle push until you hear it click into place. Very solid. Once that is done, lock it into place with the drive mounting screws. Once the drive is locked into place, slide the top of the enclosure over the chassis and lock them together with the little screws.

I don't plan to use this enclosure regularly and I decided against attaching the silicon feet. In fact, I only installed a drive into the enclosure to make sure it works and to give it a rundown for the forum. If you install the feet, you're supposed to place them between special marks on the bottom of the enclosure. Personally, if I were to use them, I'd place them elsewhere because using the marks would cover the little screws that attach the top of the enclosure to the chassis. Placing them eslwehere allows easy access to the screws in the event you want to swap out the drive.

Since my mac pro doesn't have USB 3.0 or Esata, Firewire 800 is my sole option for connecting it. I connected it to the tower and powered it up. The LED illuminated and Hardware Growler informed me JMicron is now connected to the computer. It's safe to say, this is the Sans Digital enclosure. The drive showed up immediately and access appears nice and speedy. The light blinks as you access the data on the drive.

The enclosure is super quiet. The only noise that came from it was from the drive mechanism. Unlike the Seagate enclosure which got very warm to the touch, the Sans Digital box runs much cooler. Likely, this is due to the superior design.

All in all, this is a nice enclosure. It's not as rock solid as a Weibetech enclosure - you can run them over with a truck and probably damage the tire - but definitely a huge step above the generic enclosures readily available at places like Newegg.com and Micro Center. I'm glad I bought it and I'd buy another without hesitation. Maybe even at full price.

Robert
Reply
#2
I got mine today and added comments to the original thread which I'll copy here too.

http://forums.macresource.com/read.php?1,1604956

Robert M wrote:
jdc,

I saw that deal yesterday and was trying my best to avoid it. I don't really need another external enclosure. But, $20.00 (after rebate) for an enclosure that supports Firewire 800, Esata _and_ USB 3.0? And, one that has an on/off switch. And, one, based on a review I saw elsewhere, doesn't automatically spin down the drive? Yups! I grabbed it. Mackenfrackenfrickenfracken.

I read a review that stated the USB 3.0 flavor doesn't spin drives down. This may be a good thing. I had a Seagate GoFlex enclosure that refused to work properly when connected to an Airport Extreme. It spun down and dropped its connection. Made it near impossible to use for wireless Time Machine backups.

The Sandisk enclosure may not have this issue because it doesn't spin down the drive. That it also has an on/off switch is an added plus. I _hate_ enclosure that lack a power switch.

Robert

Mine arrived and I did quick tests, maybe Robert M will be happy, but I find this annoying. The enclosure will NEVER allow the drive to spin down, even when commanded by the computer. So, it will continue to generate heat and consume power continuously when not in use.

I can see people having problems if the enclosure decides when to spin a drive up/down, but there are also commands sent by the computer/OS to control drive spinup/down and I find it very annoying if those are ignored. I have drives connected to my home server that are used for SuperDuper backups. The family computers wakup and run a backup over the network at 1AM, it takes about 30 minutes. The drive storing the backups only needs to spin for 30 minutes per day, and doesn't need to consume an extra 10 watts the rest of the time.

I like the three choices of fast interfaces on this enclosure and I'll keep it for times when I'm doing large drive cloning operations, but due to this one flaw, it's unusable for my everyday application.


Edit: Did some more testing, trying both FW-800 and USB2 (I don't have a USB3 Mac, or an ESATA interface)

The lack of spin down occurs with both FW and USB.

I tried SMART Utility with it's driver for external drives installed, it was able to see the drive and SMART Status using USB, but not FireWire. There are two separate controllers on the logic board.

The main chips on the board are

ASMedia ASM1051E http://www.asmedia.com.tw/eng/e_show_pro...hp?item=96
JMicron JMB355 http://www.jmicron.com/Product_JMB355.htm
LSI FW843 http://www.lsi.com/products/networkingco...FW843.aspx
Reply
#3
Thank you GGD. I have absolutely no use for an enclosure that doesn't allow a drive to spin down-- not regretting letting this one slip by.
Reply
#4
Other observations. The enclosure has some sheet metal tabs that the 3.5" drive sits on, and the drive mounting screws attach from the sides rather than from the bottom.

Although not designed for this, a 2.5" drive will fit and attach tightly to the SATA connector on the bridge board, but there is no way to attach mounting screws. Also, the 2.5" drive's PC board on it's bottom will be resting on one of the sheet metal tabs, so some electrical tape on that tab might be wise.

As mentioned in a lot of reviews that I've read, the Blue LED is really bright. Also the LED is on the bridge board in the rear of the enclosure by the connectors, not in the front. I actually prefer it that way.
Reply
#5
I was tempted by that deal, but that's dying tech. It would be on the shelf collecting dust within a year and the deal came around just as I'm doing my first thunderbolt fiddling about. Too much stuff gathering dust already.

But I have an older San Disk eSATA (port multiplier) box and it's been a wonderful TANK of an external device. It often runs 24/7 for weeks. Never a hiccup. Four drives funneled through one esata cable. I was able to move dual disk RAIDs from the mac pro to this box and back again. No problem. I got it for $30 off the usual $149 price in 2010 - a very good deal at the time. I've been very happy with it. I'd do it again in a heartbeat.

I'm sure you'll be pleased with this purchase.

the one that I own is below - now discontinued...

Reply
#6
Well, since Hal started reviewing cases other than the one Robert M. so graciously reviews for us...

I just ordered (thanks to Bazookamans post yesterday) an Oyen Digital Mobius 5-bay FW800/USB3/eSATA/RAID/JBOD/M-O-U-S-E Kitchen Sink case.
http://oyendigital.com/hard-drives/store/3R5-EB3-M.html

I'll know in about a week how it does... I just ordered a Western Digital 4TB drive to be "Bay 1" in it.

Got some server issues with one server setup, and some drive issues with a second server, and not enough "extra" drive space to start moving things around.
Reply
#7
I still say the best single drive external enclosures you can get are from our sponsor. The Mercury Elite Pro and Elite Pro Mini are awesome enclosures backed by a company you know you can trust. I'd rather pay a little more and have something I know will work and work well.
Reply
#8
Golfer wrote:
I still say the best single drive external enclosures you can get are from our sponsor. The Mercury Elite Pro and Elite Pro Mini are awesome enclosures backed by a company you know you can trust. I'd rather pay a little more and have something I know will work and work well.

Don't disagree... I have (between work, home, and my Mom's backup drive) six Mercury Elite Pro's. Love 'em.
They just didn't have the right mix of features for me this time.

You DO have to admit, that at the sale price Robert M. got that case for, it's a pretty darn nice deal.
Reply
#9
Paul F. wrote:
[quote=Golfer]
I still say the best single drive external enclosures you can get are from our sponsor. The Mercury Elite Pro and Elite Pro Mini are awesome enclosures backed by a company you know you can trust. I'd rather pay a little more and have something I know will work and work well.

Don't disagree... I have (between work, home, and my Mom's backup drive) six Mercury Elite Pro's. Love 'em.
They just didn't have the right mix of features for me this time.

You DO have to admit, that at the sale price Robert M. got that case for, it's a pretty darn nice deal.
Yes, that was a GREAT price. And I've picked up most my Mercury Elites up during OWC garage sales, I think I gave $45 or there abouts for the minis and little more than that for the 3.5" Elites. I don't have any of the USB 3 enclosures though, only USB 2, but I don't have any USB 3 machines yet.
Reply
#10
You could add the extender cable to get eSATA on your MP

http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Newer%20T...y/MPQXES2/
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)