Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pseudo-science or good health? Food blogger claims you are eating beaver urine
#1
I am all for eating better and consuming less processed foods but some of the claims the health blogger and the methods she uses sounds questionable to me.

Claims of "Food Babe" including the alarming notion of beaver urine is in food. Read the article to see how she makes her conclusions.
http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and..._your.html

Hari tirelessly reminds her blog readers that the next time they take licks of vanilla ice cream or spoonfuls of strawberry oatmeal, “there’s a chance you’ll be swirling secretions from a beaver’s anal glands around in your mouth.” It surely drives traffic: Tell me you wouldn’t click on a link to “Do You Eat Beaver Butt?” She is referring to castoreum, which is indeed extracted from a pair of sacs found on the rear end of a beaver, though not from the anal glands. Castoreum has been used in unguents and medicines for more than 2,000 years, but the Food Babe was appalled to discover the Food and Drug Administration considers castoreum to be not gross but GRAS—“generally recognized as safe” for both food and pharmaceutical uses.


The use of scare tactics says a lot to me when you think about the near impossibility of collecting enough beaver urine to add to foods. How would they hire people for this task?
Now Hiring: Beaver Urine Collector, enjoy the great outdoors, long hikes, hands-on intimate connections with nature. Includes health, dental, 401k. Call 555-555-5555.


The language is quite frank in this Gawker article where "Food Babe" is called out by "Science Babe".
http://tinyurl.com/oksly88
Reply
#2
Crazy makes the world an entertaining place...
Reply
#3
I don't think I'm clicking whether they are collecting two legged or 4 legged beaver urine.
Reply
#4
Well, yeah. If you subscribe to the fact that our planet is 4 billion+ years old, and you can't destroy matter, everything in our atmosphere has been recycled tens if not hundreds of millions of time. That carbon in the Kleenex you just used might once have once been T Rex crap. Or worse.

That wine? Nitrogen from prehistoric sheep foreskin.

Ambergris? Whale vomit used in perfumes. Let's dab puke on our cheeks.

None of this is new. Just that someone is paying attention to a blogger, and THAT brings the concept to our attention? That's the sad part.


This just in..... Fish pee in the water they swim in!
Reply
#5
billb wrote:
I don't think I'm clicking whether they are collecting two legged or 4 legged beaver urine.

The links are two stories about the blogger, not any link to the blogger's site. It is an interesting glimpse into what some people are convincing themselves is good and healthy science. It also shows that bloggers such as this are gaining some appeal, even appearing on shows such as Dr. Oz. For some people, if it is on TV or internet, it must be true.
Reply
#6
gawker link doesn't go anywhere.
Reply
#7
Sam3 wrote:
gawker link doesn't go anywhere.

Link should work now that I used tinyurl
Reply
#8
Wait-there are beaver farms for the extraction of castoreum? Anyone ever seen a beaver farm?
Reply
#9
Yes, it's true.
Reply
#10
Disgusting! Now, pass the sausage.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)