Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
First week with the My Touch, a mini user review
#1
Alright, I'll admit it. I really wanted an iPhone. But, AT&T was just too much more money. My plan with T-Mobile: unlimited minutes, inc. long distance and roaming, $49.99/month, data plan for unlimited web access and 400 text messages, $24.99 - total - $75/month plus some taxes. AT&T's charge for the same thing is over $135/month. So that really settled it.

Here's my impressions, so far. OK, first, I've never had an iPhone, but I have an iPod Touch so I'm familiar with the OS. I'm pretty impressed by Android. When you first fire it up it links up to your gmail account and imports all your contacts, plus it put all the info from my SIM card into the directory. Very easy start up procedure. 3G web speed is way faster than WiFi on my iPod Touch, and everything else seems to work just fine. Probably similar to the 3G iPhone's performance I'd guess.

The Google maps alone is worth the price for me, since I drive cab. I can throw away my Thomas Guide. The traffic function is very impressive and really useful during rush hour (I'm sure its the same for the iPhone, too, but it is a Google product). It gives you the option of using GPS, which claims more battery usage, or it locates the nearest cell phone tower to give you a position. I've been using the second option, which is the default setting, and its fine for my purposes.

There's a ton of free and minimal cost app's available, but I have only downloaded a few that I find useful, like internet radio, a couple different calendars, a different music player, a better touch keyboard, a shortcut to Wikipedia without launching the browser, etc. There seems to be multiple options for all these and one can spend a lot of time sifting through them. The browser is from Firefox and works well but I'm not crazy about the way it handles bookmarks. There are some free apps that supposedly do bookmarks better but I haven't tried any out yet. The iPhone has the lead on apps but since Android is open source and has been around for a year or so (?) there seems to be a lot of options and more coming all the time. Way more than I need.

Physically the My Touch is somewhat smaller than the iPhone, but the screen is nearly the same. Its easy to carry around and I don't feel like the slightly smaller screen is a deficit. The touch screen feels just like the one on my iPod except it doesn't use the two fingered commands. The battery is great - really lasts a long time. I've always had 30 or 40% left after playing around with it all day. In the morning it charges back up in a half hour or so. The back pops off for easy access to the battery as well as the SIM and SD card which is interchangeable (this easy access to everything is a very nice feature). It charges through its single USB port. I had no trouble booting up the SD on my iMac. You can drag and drop files on it, like mp3's, photos, etc, and get them in to the phone that way. Not sure if it will play Apple Lossless files -I'd guess not - but I won't be using it to play music, anyway (I use my iPod Touch for that). The music player is really barebones - no EQ, etc. There's several other freeware players that are better than the stock one. It has a 3 megapixel camera that takes pretty good pix, but is lacking even the most basic controls, like digital zoom, contrast/exposure, etc. Someone will eventually come up with a better app, I suppose. It does video as well, but I haven't tried that yet.

They are clearly going after AT&T and Apple with this phone. The packaging and presentation are right out of the Apple playbook. It comes with a rather nice hard case with two compartments, foam pockets and elastic straps and it zips up neatly. I'm using it to carry around my iPod Touch and all the adapters and cords I need to run it in the car. Thanks, TMob.

Gotta say, for the money, its a pretty sweet deal. Your opinions will vary....
Reply
#2
How is the virtual keyboard in comparison to the iPhone/iPod Touch's?

How is the build quality of the phone? I've only played with a G1 but found it to be a typically cheap piece of HTC plastic. I'm not expecting something with the pleasing solidity of the iPhone or iPod Touch, but any improvement over the G1 would be welcomed.
Reply
#3
Nice write up on your experience with the newer My Touch. The Android platform is pretty exciting and there are supposed to be a bunch of new models out by the end of the year.

The Motorola "Sholes" on Verizon looks to be an interesting combo device - physical keyboard & touchscreen. Hopefully Motorola can pull this off as my wife really wants a decent web browsing phone with VZW coverage.

Here's an interesting perspective from one bloggers recent attempt to switch from an iPhone to a G1 for a week: http://notes.torrez.org/2009/08/google-phone-day-1.html
Reply
#4
Silencio wrote:
How is the virtual keyboard in comparison to the iPhone/iPod Touch's?

How is the build quality of the phone? I've only played with a G1 but found it to be a typically cheap piece of HTC plastic. I'm not expecting something with the pleasing solidity of the iPhone or iPod Touch, but any improvement over the G1 would be welcomed.

I was not crazy about the virtual keyboard that came with it. It was a pain to keep switching between the letters and numbers, and the spaces were so small that I kept hitting the wrong one. It takes a little messing around but you can use this one, the HTC IME which is very well thought out, and there are probably others:




Build quality is very good, much better than the G1 with the pop out keyboard that seemed like it was going to fall apart. I also think that all the complaints they received about battery life in that early model prompted them to put a better one in the My Touch. Take a look. You might be surprised.
Reply
#5
How do you install that different virtual keyboard?
Reply
#6
pinkoos wrote:
How do you install that different virtual keyboard?


T-Mobile Forum
Reply
#7
Wags wrote:
[quote=pinkoos]
How do you install that different virtual keyboard?


T-Mobile Forum
Thanks!
Reply
#8
I, too, just picked this up from Costco this weekend and am loving it so far. I'm coming from a Blackberry Pearl flip.

I'm stuck with Tmobile because I had just renewed my contract in December. I tried out an unlocked iPhone for a couple of days (I unlocked it myself), but I just didn't want to keep on dealing with issues regarding what to do if an update locks it up again, etc., etc. Just don't have the time for messing around with stuff like that anymore.

Anyway, your review is spot on with my experience. Maybe I'll add a bit more if I get some time today.

Thanks.
Reply
#9
While I find it fascinating and kind of cool that you can install different virtual keyboard software on your phone, that stuff kind of speaks to the fact that maybe the original developer should have spent more time getting the stock keyboard right. I enjoy tinkering with tech stuff as much as the next guy, but I also like to think I have a life outside of that. Having to upgrade a lot of the stock Android software -- keyboard, bookmark browser, media player -- is something that would actually keep me away from the platform.

Apple's software on the iPhone isn't exactly 100% perfect, but it's incredibly refined given the young age of the product line.
Reply
#10
Does the My Touch sych with iCal and Address Book?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)