davester wrote:
I thought most people understood this to be true so I didn't bother posting a link. The late Sony XBRs and Samsung CRTs blow all the LCDs and plasmas out of the water when it comes to picture quality.
As you said..."as long as you stick with standard def TVs less than about 32" or HDTVs less than about 40".... "
This narrowly-defined artificial restriction conveniently rules out pretty much all plasma HDTVs, leaving only LCDs to compare to. Not a realistic guide. The sweet spot home consumers aim for in 1080i or 1080p HDTVs it would be fair to say, is more likely between 42" and 50". But sure, as long as you stick within a narrowly defined-limit of eight inches, I imagine you can inflate that into a generalization about the virtues of 20-year-old Sony CRTs,which I'm sure are very good, within their size range and corresponding contrast and DPI. I'm sure he'll enjoy true HDTV when he gets an opportunity to take advantage of it.
In the original post, his comparison wasn't to a high-end plasma or LCD HDTV, his comparison was to a "flat screen" TV he saw while staying at a hotel.
Not the same thing as watching a Blu-Ray disc on a 50" plasma at a Sony store, for example, or seeing a 42" Panasonic Viera, standard-definition doesn't really compare, the best of the new HD models are a pleasure to behold, even if it's not to buy one, but to appreciate the image.
Of course, it's subjective, He might see a breathtaking HD image that's clearly more precise and beautiful, but still be completely certain, for personal reasons, that his own TV is better.
"My IT dept wanted to get me a LCD to replace my Mitsubishi Diamondtron MultiSync 21\ CRT, and I told them not until I quit, or it fails and can't be repaired. wrote:
Racer X, I used to have one of those exact models. Expensive as hell, those things, and weigh as much as a car. Great for graphics work. Not notably better than similarly-priced modern LCD displays. The publishing and print work I do is critical, but I'm not working for the Smithsonian, or the Louvre, just books and magazines. it sounds like your attachment is more sentimental than visual. Great brand, pretty decent technology for its time, I used mine for years before I happily moved to other types of displays.
I suspect you won't have to throw a fit and quit your job (the Mitsubishi Diamondtron will perish long before that) though your petulant grandstanding sounds impressive, makes me glad I'm self employed!