Replace combo drive in '08 Macbook question

[rouderon]

I have a superdrive from an '06 iMac and want to replace the combo drive in a white '08 Macbook - any way to know if it will be compatible with the Macbook before I take on this task?

[jdc]

Should work, but a TON of work.

How much does that optical drive get used? How about a $25 external instead?

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.as...6827151262

[rouderon]

Thanks! - that may be the best alternative

[hal]

I've had mixed success installing dvd drives from one unit to another, but I don't think this will fit. Pretty sure the imac drive is 15mm and the macbook is 12mm.

PS - even if it was guaranteed to work, I'd probably still opt for an external

[sekker]

Good external BR drives are under $50.